I listen for you.
But I am no good at hearing.
For you, my God speak quietly; a whisper.
Hints of your love
blow in the grasses,
the bird’s song,
the wind wafting in the trees,
in children’s laughter.
I listen for you.
Help me to hear.

Where do we form our ideas about God? And more importantly when? How young does it begin to register in your head and heart, your idea of God as a masculine figure and that your daddy is also male? How did they become so mixed together, mingled and intertwined?
And I asked myself today. How do you pull them apart, which you must for a variety of reasons but most of all because you don’t know how to pray to that God. You don’t know that God.
What if you grew up feeling that you will never measure up, never have a day in your small, inconsequential life of being good enough, no matter what you do. What if you grew up believing that your life, whatever you become, whatever you might
Hope for, dream or wish, whatever you might be today isn’t enough?
What if you have believed since you were a very young girl, that all your striving will make Daddy love you more and yet it doesn’t work? Did not work. What then?
What if you learned that God isn’t male? What if God isn’t just a daddy or a father but a mother, a healer, even a lover? God is something beyond our comprehension, wild and incredible, beyond imagination.
How are we to pull those ideas apart, with their
Deep Roots that have grown up all over us, entangled
with one another, clinching our chest tighter year after year – strangling,
smothering,
killing you.
I know that I cannot separate these things. In my human effort it’s impossible to make my shouting, critical, mean-spirited, controlling, effortlessly (it seemed) horrible and cruel daddy to stop.
I have to throw that idea away. I have to toss that idea of human daddy being God or or God being like my daddy, toss it far into the ocean with all the other idols I have collected in my life. I’ve got a few, but this one is a huge Monster of an idol and in my power I cannot even lift it, to toss it away into the vast murky universal ocean.
I cannot.
So I sit here, on the beach. My feet sandy, my toes getting wet just a little, I pick up a pebble and fling it as far as I can. I do not see how far flies, but I know that it is gone.
My hand is empty.
I imagine that I hear it fall, then swirl down into the waves, the tide pulling it out, further and further away
from me.
That’s how far I toss the idol of my human daddy being my God.
Out of my mind.
out of my heart,
out of my life,
daddy’s gone. Human-daddy-formed-god, to be replaced with …
Something New, that I do not know yet.
“God is not limited by gender because God is Spirit.” – Mimi Haddad
I want to know that God.
So I am going to stay here on the beach a little while longer waiting, hoping, dreaming, believing that this God, who I cannot even comprehend yet, wants to know me.
Melody
“The point of the incarnation was that Christ represents your flesh and mine. Perhaps for this reason, Christ’s self-appointed name was most frequently Son of Man (anthropos—humankind) not Son of Male (aner). Gendered deities were part of the Greek dualistic system, which Jesus, as your flesh and mine, stands against.” – Mimi Haddad, CBE
So I’m trying something new. Picking a subject at random that I seem to obsess about or fixate on, something that grips my imagination in compulsive and ugly ways, (I started with one of my secret obsessions.) I’ll write honestly without a lot self-editing or controlling “the message” to see what comes out. No answers. No over spiritualizing. Just the real, gritty, sometimes awkward me. I’m trying to push myself in my style to loosen up a little. Have you noticed that I take myself a bit too seriously? This is my second excursion into a different kind of real.
Parenting surely is the most difficult job I’ve ever had. Many times in a day I think “I am not qualified.” But it’s too late, for those regrets.
No one is qualified to be a parent, not really.
Yesterday, I was reflecting on our exceptionally verbal, strong as steel, at times tyrannical daughter who is so like my father! I just wanted to fall down on my knees, humbled by my own lack. Again, as if a prayer, whispering this time as a lament: I am not qualified to be a mother.
I went through most of my life in some strange, surreal auto pilot.
I went through forty years utterly afraid of life. I sometimes think back, strange as it sounds and wonder aloud how I even survived the catastrophes of living in our home. My father’s spirit and soul crushing rage destroyed me, my personality and I spent many years just grieving who I might be, might have been. That sort of grief is debilitating.
Oh there were moments, especially outside of home, where I found parts of myself. I loved my youth pastor; he listened to me and allowed for my incessant questions about the Bible. He listened to my ideas and fears. He never once yelled at me, or told me my sarcasm or sense of humor or quick thinking and verbal sparring was bad. He somehow validated me and I loved him.
But for the most part I went through my tens and twenties and thirties heart-sick, depressed, and afraid.
So when my daughter rages at me (I told you she is like my dad) or the world, or she stands up to me, or questions … every little thing, a small part of me is cheering inside!!
She is alive.
She is breathing, kicking and screaming, going into the world believing that her thoughts, her questions, her jokes, her ideas matter and for that I am so pleased.
She is alive and I am slowly coming alive too. I believe my father had to die for me to begin living. A new friend, after hearing about the childhood that I had said to me yesterday “It’s a wonder that I have any faith at all.”
I am simply grateful I am alive. Yes, this life of believing is really hard; harder for me than it seems to be for many people I know. I’ve come to accept and understand this to be a part of what makes me, me. And yes, this is something I embrace.
I may not be qualified, but I am grateful to be alive.
I’ve been quiet, because the world is so loud. So many days I just cannot do anything more than put my hands over my ears and shut it all out.
This world where exegesis and hermeneutic and “being right “are more important than generosity and love.
A world where the decision of the Church or the Government feeding the hungry becomes intellectual and spiritual sport.
A world critical of mystical devotion of Henri Nouwen whom I revere.
A world where conviction over sexuality and what is or is not love makes people hate one another, aren’t we all God’s creatures?
A world where your or my “place” and opportunities depend on being born a boy or a girl; where little boys refuse to let a little girl play ball. just because she’s a girl.
The world, even the Church that cannot agree on much of anything. And sometimes I think how Jesus must just weep over us all.
This world is upside down, crazy and it just makes me sad, even deeply wounded by it.
I’ve been quiet because I have been writing. And I find that blogging makes me want more clicks, and comments, and there is never enough attention. It feeds the part of my soul is ugly, that longs for significance. Blogging doesn’t suit this heart .
Empty, shaken, longing for solitude, then I know. I need more of Jesus.
I’ve been quiet because I’ve been writing and when I write I doubt. I doubt my Call. I doubt my talent. I doubt that these things that tug on my heart, these words that seem so clear, that wake me up from a dead sleep, that dance around me like pixies while I mow the straight lines of the lawn, that chatter inside me telling me I’m stupid.
Yes, I’ve been quiet because when I write I doubt myself, and
this too is a challenge of a person who finds herself committed to words — to creating and giving them away.
I don’t know enough.
I don’t have a big enough audience.
I don’t say things that matter.
I don’t know much of anything.
Seeing a theme here, I, I, I, …
I get even more so — I need deep quiet. And I know again that I need to drink from the spigot that is of forgiveness and true purpose and being transformed. When Jesus said “I have come” he meant come to stay. He’s here with us. He’s here by my side, as I tap-tap-tap on the laptop.
More of him,
less of me.
That means deep quiet.
Only
[and every day]
empty.
I wake starved for more of you. Then
the day prevails, trouble
gathers about my feet, pulls on my leg, swirling
fury.
Life is loud and you God
are a quiet wind, but a whisper. I must earnestly and expectantly listen,
for you.
If only I would.
Start again.
Only and every
day
empty, keening for you.
I never wanted to be like my mother.
My mother stayed for more than 40 years in a marriage that broke her heart. She admits now that she was afraid.
She married in the late fifties, when women couldn’t even have a bank account in their name. She was a teacher and worked to put my father through college. In the first year of their marriage, in a rage my father put her head through the wall. He promised to never do it again. And to my knowledge he kept that promise. But that was the beginning of being manipulated. He threatened and he yelled.
The man could rage.
The smallest thing would set him off.
I never wanted to be like my mother, because all those years, I thought she was weak. Weak for staying.
Or so I thought, for many years, until I became a mother. And when that happened I began over time to see that she did it all for us.
My mother is strong. She stayed for us. She was the buffer all those years between us and my father’s angry raging. She took it more than we did. (And we took it a lot.)
And in later years as the weight of it became more than she could bear, she began to find comfort in the bottle. I never wanted to be like my mother, but I became an alcoholic too. I buried my fears for years in the numbing relief of alcohol. As is often the case in a family with addiction, I carried it on. And in the end I realized, I am very like my mother. I hide my pain even now, though I have been sober for almost five years.
I am strong and would do anything for my kids, just like my mother.
I never wanted to be like my mother, but I am.
I am strong, loyal and sober.
Happy Mother’s Day, 2012
Melody
I’ve written about my alcoholism here.
I’ve written about my Dad here.

The jubilee that I thought this life would be,
is more often drudgery, a never-ending ache, stinging salty tears,
an albatross, when I had imagined my grown up days to be a dance.
Clinging to the Cross, I trace its rough textures, acutely
knowing what is there.
For I know my own failings to my core,
my dim
faith, my inner weaknesses, flaws and faults,
dearth
of wisdom, a crooked unforgiving heart, my lack
of love more frequent than not.
This life is bittersweet.
This infinitely
fearful heart is not sensing
glory
and I ask, when does the splendor begin?
And then I hear the Holy One’s whisper:
I AM the Peace you seek.
Keep clinging.
Pu-leeeese, don’t tell me to lighten up – I take great pride in my seriousness.
It’s a part of my M.O. It’s not that I don’t laugh at all, I do. And I love to laugh till I cry, tears streaming uncontrollably at something my little sister said or the guy next to me at Bible study, who absolutely cannot let anything go without a wise ass remark. Oh that’s me making the sarcastic reply under my breath. It’s both of us giggling disobediently and with such pleasure, ducking a scowl from our leader. Do not make eye contact. Or at my husband Tom’s witticisms — he is frequently cracking me up.
But in all earnestness, the world is so damn sad. Don’t you agree? Or it is just me? I am a bleeding heart “liberal” yawl. How can you not wake up with the weight of the world on your shoulders, especially if you are the parent of teenagers? Or have bills. Or just turn on the news?
I find myself exclaiming about or at least ranting, and aching and hurting over many things.
These things are heavy. These things matter.
I expressly get upset about mean kids. Where do kids learn to hate? Why can we not represent Jesus better? And love any child no matter their sexual orientation? What would Jesus do, indeed?
I could go on, but this is about joy right? I do need to lighten up. I cannot even talk JOY for five minutes? Sheesh.
I found myself saying in a group recently I don’t “do joy.” Awkward silence there and I can feel it here now. (It’s not that I’m against it in theory. I just don’t know how to get some.)
I know that it is good to laugh!. I just don’t know how in and of myself , I have always been slightly melancholy — the only time I am an incoherently laughing kind of person is when others are having fun around me — they bring the fun out of me. I am the sort that has to work for joy.
The next best thing is Tim Hawkins (I know how’d I get here?) who has “the magical blend between two comedic ideals: A genuinely funny comedy show that caters to the entire family. ” This guy makes me pee in my pants, he’s so funny. It’s good clean fun and it feels so good to enjoy his shows.
Check him out won’t you?
It’s all I could think of,
now back to my regular programming.
———————————————-
This was written as a part of the May 2012 Synchroblog centered on the idea of what it might mean to lighten up a little–personally, spiritually, professionally, or in any area of our lives. You can write about why that’s easy or hard for you, share something funny or humorous, or any other angle that feels easy and right (remember, part of this is about lightening up!)
These are the wonderful people that participated. (I don’t know them personally.)
I have reflected on the idea of prayer and I am reading (with a friend) the wonderful book Prayer by Hans Urs von Balthasar. This book is so rich that I’m left both breathless for more, even while being totally flabbergasted by his meaty thoughts. I find myself studiously copying down paragraph after paragraph. I will be writing on prayer soon, after I have more time to learn from friends on the topic and think.
I don’t get prayer – it isn’t easy for me to understand or practice. And the longer I am a person of faith the more crazy I feel in group prayer meetings. I’d value any insights.
Also, I’m thinking about the tensions and paradox of the life of faithfulness to God pursuing this illusive life of a writer.
I scribbled this down earlier in the week in my moleskin.
If someone would tell ME
or tell THE WORLD that something
I wrote
move them, and I
would choose for them to tell THE WORLD, then
I know that I write for the wrong reasons.
Forgive me.
Other than that. I will leave you to the rest of your Sunday – whether you practice Sabbath or not, I hope you will enjoy a moment, walking through the Botanical Gardens of Madison.
If you’d like to see my whole set of the walk through Madison’s Botanical Gardens, it is here.
Melody
With some friends,
you take down the words, moments
are scribbled onto your heart.
For their life
is a book of wisdom.
Leaning
forward, keening
for a moment of clarity
and goodness, even
as if you are sitting together in a holy place.
Sacred space
is created
in the meeting of spirits, souls
mystically blended,
time stops
with some friends.
Yesterday as I was sitting across from one of the people I respect most in the world when my life changed forever.
You see I have had many long years of being in pain about being a woman in the church, though I am on a path of healing. Yes, this story does have a happy-ish ending.
Okay happy isn’t quite right but I feel hopeful in the knowledge that we have not seen the end of Our Story.
Being a woman in the evangelical Church can be painful. Being a natural questioner is too.
More than a decade ago, I began to question the roles of women in the evangelical church and this has brought me a lot of personal pain. The process of learning what was True – scriptural, cultural, and relevant for us today, was slow and difficult because no one really wanted to talk to me about it or help all that much, as I questioned my pastor, and the elders, and pursued it with others.
Little did I know that in some cases it was because others didn’t really know what they thought.
This is a part of what makes this issue so slippery. I pushed, sought clarification, and ask for perspectives and read a lot of books! The process of the last ten years has been uncomfortable, isolating and even at times agonizing.
I learned recently that I have even scored a “reputation.”
Not as I would hope of being a thinking, theological person – because I have asked the biblical basis for these things and sought truth. That I would take as a backhanded compliment.
And not as I might wish for being a questioner –because I do have many questions and never saw that as liability as a person of faith.
Rather, I have been called the f-word, yeah that f-word – Feminist. And even more malevolent, an “Angry Feminist.”
Actually, the angry part is true. Once I am able to step back from my defensive, hurt posture, I’ll confess that I have been angry. I have carried around inside me, close to my heart, an oozing, pussy, and infected spiritual sore and this has been very bad for my soul. I even picked incessantly at it. I have been wounded, offended, bitter and angry and worst of all to me is this.
I have felt unheard.
Sitting there across from my beautiful, big-hearted and loving, Bible cherishing, Jesus following, Holy Spirit filled, Bible Church attending friend, she uttered the most unbelievable words. And she repeated them when I seemed to just look at her bug-eyed, in shock.
“You are not alone. You are not the only one wondering what’s true,” she whispered to me.
She asked me this simple question:
“What did Jesus say about women?”
Well, nothing that I am aware of and I will double-check because she asked. But I am not aware of anything prescriptive that Jesus said about women.
Jesus saw women,
Jesus spoke to women,
Jesus healed women,
Jesus taught women,
Jesus was financially supported by women,
Jesus loved women,
Jesus listened to women?
Jesus was persuaded to change his mind by a woman.
All in a culture and time when women were unseen and unheard, unworthy, unquestioningly invisible.
So I ask you friends. What did Jesus say about women? And what parts of Scripture bring you hope as you consider the place of women in the church today?
I’ve had a healing of that sore that I allowed to fester for more than a decade. That incredible story is here.
And I have a renewed challenge by my friend, someone who I never thought would ask about the injustices toward women in the Church. Because of her, I now dream of somehow bringing a riptide of change into the middle of this vast ocean of tradition and tired beliefs which have been calcified into orthodoxy.
These days, most days, I feel hope about the place of women in the Church. Other days it feels foolish and the lack of certainty is soul crushing.
On the days that I maintain my weak hold on Jesus, I do believe change will come. And hearing the questions coming from this dear friend meant everything.
I am resolved to begin again to study and write on this topic — I gave it up for a good long while. The angry feminist in me has become resolved and certain of Jesus and his love for me and all women. Something shifted in my mind and heart , in my soul as I sat listening to my friend.
I am not alone. I am not the only one asking. I am not the only woman looking for answers. We will find the Truth together. We have not seen the end of Our Story.
MelodyOther things I have written on these subjects.
//
It was stunning for me to realize that I had no anxiety the entire time I was away at the Festival of Faith & Writing. The thought of returning home brought the familiar burning in my chest — so unwelcome. I do not want to accept its presence. And just for a minute I know that I must drill down and try to find the truth there, asking myself Can I figure out why I am afraid of coming home?
There was a small sense in which this place, this moment wasn’t real.
Just as I lament to myself (a regular foible of mine, to be sure) that I didn’t have any real relationships here at the festival, another part of me knows that it was quite wonderful to wander anonymously. Soaking in wisdom and not be expected to say anything. I didn’t have to be wise or special in any way. I could many times, for hours on end, not utter a single word to another human being; which I found was peaceful, even liberating. (Not speaking except perhaps to an infrequent stranger in a seminar, so that I wouldn’t come off a weirdo.)
But mostly, I was silent.
I wasn’t even writing this week. My head was going, of course. Especially my dreams which were full of thoughts, words, conjectures and I would wake every morning with all that magical and perplexing jumble. Words. Ideas. Inspiration came unbidden, naturally, because of all the incredible people and ideas surrounding. And then it would drift away as my mind became clear and the caffeine settled into my veins.
And then, we return home and there it is. The fear.
Here it is. I didn’t have the sense this week that God is disappointed in me. It was gone – that feeling that is always hovering in and around me that I’m not measuring up. The legacy of a childhood gone awry, the anger and disappointment of my human father killing joy.
Where did it go and why did it have to return? Drilling down, still further, to that little place where I feel God’s displeasure. I have a hunch this is not of God or from God at all.
I was having this amazing conversation at dinner with Tom. He expressed his belief that most American Christians have this lover relationship with God, I knew that I don’t. I have a disappointed-with-me-and-angry-at-me-parent type of relationship with God.
I think I know God. Fact is I hardly know God. If he is even knowable fully in a human lifetime, I sure doubt it. And God knows everything about me. And God is very much not disappointed with me. In fact he’s thrilled. He made me to be a creative, a thinker, a deeply passionate, mostly introverted whittler of words and pictures.
And God likes me – generally.
Of course I’m am still an ugly sinner. Deeply aware of my spiritual lack. Needing a Holy filling daily, even moment by moment. Needing a Holy shaping, a changing by the beautiful Potter who is creating something beautiful out of the pieces and parts of my little life.
No, he’s not disappointed and there it is, that’s the source of my anxiety. That’s the place that I must return to work on, over and over, and again, even as I perfect this craft of writing it is the being that matters most. I must always, and frequently, sit with him and allow the Holy One to perfect me.
It’s a homecoming I am unused to — this beautiful welcome he is offering. It is so good to know that I am home.